Examiner John Blum and applicant Darlene Woelfel tell, together, how a May 3, 2023 multi-engine checkride in a Piper Seneca became a real emergency when a bang from the tail took away pitch control. With Bobby Doss and Jay Robinson, they walk through the fight all the way to the ground, the landing in a clearing near the Sam Houston National Forest, the recovery, and the retest with the same examiner.
In episode E207 of Behind the Prop, host Bobby Doss and co-host Jay Robinson of United Flight Systems sit down with both people from one cockpit: examiner John Blum and applicant Darlene Woelfel. On May 3, 2023, over the Sam Houston National Forest, Darlene was on her commercial multi-engine add-on checkride in a Piper Seneca when, after steep turns and while slowing to blue line, a metallic bang came from the tail and the nose pitched up about 50 degrees. John, a retired United 777 captain who now examines in Lone Star College's Part 141 program, describes the stall and dive cycles, control forces neither pilot could overcome, and how mid-range power settings damped the oscillations. Darlene, who trained in Lone Star College's collegiate program and rented aircraft at United Flight Systems through it, explains stepping into the crew role: the Mayday call, the squawk code under heavy G-loads, and the gear and flap decisions on the way down. They cover seeing light through cracks in the fuselage, aiming for the clearing they had spotted during their clearing turns, using green treetops to bleed off speed, shutting down the engines and electrics to limit fire risk, and getting out and getting help. Darlene shares her recovery, the long FAA medical process, the discontinuance, and retesting with the same examiner, and John explains why an examiner and an applicant have to become a team the moment something real happens. Now a CFI and CFII, Darlene says she looks for every cotter pin on her preflight.
00:00
Behind the Prop Intro
This is Behind the Prop with United Flight Systems owner and licensed pilot Bobby Doss, and his co-host, major airline captain and designated pilot examiner Wally Mulhearn. Now let's go behind the prop.
00:24
Bobby Doss
What's up, Wally? Oh, wait, Wally couldn't be with us tonight. What's up, Jay?
00:30
Jay Robinson
Not much, Bobby. How's it going?
00:33
Bobby Doss
Fantastic as always. Tonight, we have another great show. If you listen often, you listened to the last episode, we interviewed a gentleman who walked into a prop, and it went through his body three times. It was horrific, and he lived to tell about it, and, he was a commercial pilot or commercial student at the time. It was a crazy story. This one might actually have it beat. The title of this show was, My Checkride Ended With a Crash, and we have a couple of people on the show, but imagine this, it's May 3rd, 2023, blue skies, no wind, a perfect checkride day over the Sam Houston National Forest. Steep turns were nailed, then slowing to blue line in a Seneca, a bang like a shotgun from the tail, and the yoke slammed into both of their chests. The applicant looked at the examiner like, is this part of the test? It wasn't.
01:28
Bobby Doss
Tonight, both of them from the cockpit are here to tell the story. The examiner who flew it into the trees, and the applicant who became part of his crew and used to fly at United Flight Systems. I'm Bobby Doss, and this is Behind the Prop. Welcome to the show, Darlene and John. I can't believe y'all are both here and survived. We can't wait to tell the story to our listeners. Thank you for joining us.
01:50
Darlene Woelfel
Thanks for having us.
01:52
Bobby Doss
Thank you. So, I've listened to a lot, I've read a lot. Darlene, we know each other. John, we know each other. Jay's been involved in both of y'all's lives. The aviation community in the greater Houston area is pretty small. I kind of want to talk about the before the bang. You both obviously worked together. Darlene, you were training at a Part 141 school. Tell us about the training up to this point. I think this was your multi-engine checkride, correct?
02:19
Darlene Woelfel
Yeah, that's right. Commercial multi add-on. At the point I had commercial single, I had instrument, everything beyond that. I was working as a dispatcher at the school, so I was really familiar with all of our planes. I knew John from our ground school classes at the college. And at that point, John was always kind of like this legendary figure, and all the students could say that, you know, he has all this experience, very, very, I guess, kind of mellow guy. But he had a, had a good reputation. And going through this, I got to learn a lot more about John, which I'm, you know, really pleased to say that he's my friend and mentor at this point. So that's kind of where I was at before this.
03:06
Bobby Doss
So all of you out there listening who might have a multi-engine checkride, your day won't go like this, hopefully, but, it was a crazy day. And John, we know each other, but you are part of a Part 141 school that has self-examining authority, I believe. So you're not a designated pilot examiner, but you were the examiner that day for Darlene's checkride. Is that correct? Is that a way to describe it?
03:27
John Blum
Right, we call it a designated program examiner. So I, I was doing checkrides, for our students within the school under self-examining authority from, FA Part 141.
03:41
Bobby Doss
Awesome. So, John, a little bit about your experience and where you've come from. I, I know it, but the listeners don't. Tell us, tell us your aviation background up to, up to this point.
03:53
John Blum
Well, it's, kind of covered a lot of years, you know, kind of, you know, ever since I was, was a kid, wanting to learn how to fly. So that was way more than fifty years ago when I, when I started flying. And, did a, a lot of GA flight instructing and owned my own FBO and flight school, kind of like you, Bobby and Jay. The, experience led me to corporate flying and then to regional carriers and then, then to United. I started in, 1979 and, retired from United in 2018 and, left United as a triple seven captain and, and, came to Lone Star College just a few months after I retired. I got home, and I don't know if you all thought about retirement, but it isn't, it isn't for me.
04:44
John Blum
And, I was at home about three months, and my wife said, don't you have someplace to go? And I heard about the, the, program starting at Lone Star, and I applied and was hired there in, in May of 2019, and I've been there ever since. So, and during that time, you know, Not only were we operating the flight school and the ground school, but I kept my hand in the flying. I, I did a little bit of, of training, but I kind of let that go to the, you know, the instructors, which they're there to build the time and get the experience. And I would fill in here and there doing, doing the checkrides and then primarily doing multi-engine cause, you know, I'd rather do the multi-engine flying than sit in the, in the Cessna cause it's getting harder and harder to get in and out of that airplane at, time.
05:36
John Blum
Then it got even harder after we had this little issue in the Seneca. So I, I, I love aviation. I, I, I care very deeply about the students that are in our charge. You know, whether it's, you know, flying with one of our instructors or going through ground school. So aviation's a close-knit, you know, fraternity, and, and I really believe that and want to leave a, a, a solid mark on all of the students, anybody that comes in contact with it, so they can be safe, they can enjoy it, and that they have a long, long experience like I enjoyed. And, I wish I could go back, but I can't. You know, there's, there's those rules out there that say you can't do that anymore, but I'm enjoying what I'm doing now.
06:21
Bobby Doss
That's awesome. And so, your experience obviously leads you both to where you're at on May third. And Darlene, my questions kind of go to you, right? I mean, you flew a UFS on, but I believe that was more along the lines of renting as part of your collegiate program, and maybe not that opportunity to rent in some of those aircraft. You, you go to Lone Star, the collegiate program. Talk to us about your experience. Very rare we have a, a student pilot. You're not a student pilot anymore, but a student pilot on the podcast that can tell us your experience with the 141 program. I think you do do some part 61 training today, as a CFI, CFII. What, what is your reflection on your experience as a 141 collegiate program, student?
07:11
Darlene Woelfel
I mean, similar like John said, like being a kid, wanting to fly, that was always my interest. And throughout high school, I was in Lone Star doing dual credit. So whenever I heard that they were starting the aviation degree, I was like, oh, this will be a really easy transfer. So I graduated high school 2020, then fall 2020, I started with the college, with the 141 school, and it was easy. I really liked how structured it was, and they had everything. At that time, they had everything in person. So a lot of things were online during 2020. But it was in person. I liked that, and we flew quite often. It was, it was still a small school at that point, small program. I liked that, and the instructors were great. They were really good people.
07:54
Bobby Doss
Yeah, so John, a question for you. Again, just some stuff before the bang. My research says you have over 34,000 hours. Is that an accurate number?
08:04
John Blum
How many did you say? Thirty-four thousand? Yeah, I don't know how to get that number, but I was just looking at the, the insurance application, you know, every year you have to fill it out, and I go, wow, that's, that's a lot, you know, been, you know, fifty-five years of flying pretty much every time I could get in the air, and I just, wow, it just accumulated like crazy, and here I am, you know, to look back on experience, and, you know, I've told Darlene and other students that it would be really nice if I could hand them experience, but we can't do that, they have to get it on their own, and Darlene's been gathering lots of experience lately, but what I can do, you know, based on that, that time, is show them what experience looks like, and, and give them some insights as to what happened over those years and years of, of flying or everything.
08:58
John Blum
Went good most of the time, but once in a while you get, get a curveball. And this one happened to be a big curveball as we, get into this situation.
09:07
Bobby Doss
It's really funny you say that because when I was, in IT before my aviation career here, I was probably Darlene's age and I thought I should be running the company. And I thought experience really wasn't, you know, aptitude and drive was more important than that experience. But hindsight being 2020 now, I didn't know how stupid I was. And it's, she's blessed that you were in that plane with her, no question. I think you have a symptom that I have though, John. We both hang out with a bunch of 20-year-old kids that keep us young.
09:38
John Blum
It keeps us young.
09:39
Bobby Doss
People ask me all the time, why do you hang out with 20-year-olds all day? And I'm like, it's kind of fun. They're not, they're never too unhappy unless the day doesn't go great for them. But everyone's excited to be at a fly school and go fly and learn from other people. But it does, Bob said it before he sold the school and I say it today, being around a bunch of young people does keep me young for sure.
10:01
John Blum
It sure does.
10:03
Bobby Doss
Jay, you worked with both of them or around them for a long, long time. What kind of questions do you have about before the bang, before things broke?
10:11
Jay Robinson
Absolutely. So I'm sure, and we'll get to it tonight, but we spend a ton of time talking about the bang and onwards. I guess, Darlene, this was your multi-engine checkride. Like, you want to tell us about kind of what that morning was like, getting ready, kind of if there was anything that caught your eye or if it was just a normal prep for a checkride for you?
10:31
Darlene Woelfel
I would say it was pretty normal. I mean, going into any checkride, you got the checkride nerves, and I was, I was clocked in dispatch actually that morning. So I think as soon as John got there, I think I clocked out. If I remember it correctly, I was like, "Okay, let's go do the checkride." And I'm, I'm studying at the front desk before he gets there. So I was nervous. But like I felt like.
10:52
Bobby Doss
Well, real quick, let's, let's be clear. Was not Jay Robinson your boss at the time he made you work?
10:56
Jay Robinson
No, this was, this was before. I was not there yet.
11:00
Bobby Doss
Yeah, you joined not too long after.
11:02
Jay Robinson
I did not make Darlene work the neighbor checkride, not me.
11:04
Darlene Woelfel
Okay. Yeah. And like I said, it was, it was a little smaller at that point. It's, it's much, it's grown to be a much larger school. But yeah, so I was dispatching, studying. I got the, the pre-checkride nerve. John's asking me questions during the preflight. And nothing out of the normal. So we, we go up there. And then we, we start to set up, we do steep turns first, and then we're setting up for slow flight, and that's whenever we hear the bang and such. And I think one of my initial reactions, you even mentioned it, I kind of looked at him like, this is part of the checkride. And like, y'all have experienced, I'm sure, minor issues, like if it's a technical issue with the GPS or something, when you're with an instructor, and like your default's kind of like, you just sit there and look at them like, oh, they'll figure it out.
11:59
Darlene Woelfel
Like, we'll see, like they'll get it. Once they fix it, it'll be fine. Like, we'll get this in two seconds. And I think, reflecting on it, I think I had kind of had that mentality like, oh, he'll figure it out and we'll just continue with the checkride.
12:12
Jay Robinson
Yeah. It'll just be another thing. Yeah. I think we talk a lot about, you know, we call it the, the bang is what everybody refers to it as, but like, can you, can you tell us more about like what it, what you heard, what did it feel like? Like, was it very sudden? Was it all at once? Just give us some more insight into that, Darlene.
12:30
Darlene Woelfel
Well, I think the sound, the best way to describe it is a bang, but I say it's like a metallic bang. Like, I guess if you hit like a garage door really hard, you can tell it's like metal hitting. So that's what it sounded like, and we could tell it was coming from the rear of the aircraft. When that happens, that's when the nose pitches up, and I think we both agreed it could have been like 50 degrees nose high. At that point, all we're seeing is sky, like all we see is blue sky. I can't remember that, that picture, and that's when we kind of switched to the like, okay, let's solve this. John's flying the, flying the plane at that point, and I kind of switched to making a mayday call and transmit.
13:09
Jay Robinson
Yeah, and I mean, I've, I've heard a lot of y'all talking about it, and I mean, the teamwork to me is amazing. Like, you know, tell us, tell us about dealing with, like, that kind of situation. Like, I imagine it was very surreal for the nose to be pointed that high, and I'm sure there were some G-forces going on. Like, what, what was it like to try to work a problem in those conditions?
13:28
Darlene Woelfel
Hard. I mean, John describes it. I, I really like sharing the story together cuz we have like two perspectives. From his perspective, he always shares like that I was like floating in my chair. I'm like, I know I was buckled in there. Like I have a lap belt, I have a shoulder harness, I'm in there. But he was like, you were flying around the place, like your headset's going all over your face. Like, so I was trying to make that, distress call in those conditions and I try to put in the, the squawk code. I try to put in 7700 and it's like a touch screen. So you're right with all those G forces, with the abrupt, pitch up and pitch down, I hit like 7600 and John's kinda like, that's okay, that's good enough.
14:08
Jay Robinson
So, it was hard.
14:11
Bobby Doss
They'll see us at this point. They'll see us.
14:13
Darlene Woelfel
Yeah, they'll know some things wrong.
14:16
Jay Robinson
Well, John, how about you? What, what went through your head when this all started happening?
14:21
John Blum
I think, most of my thinking was out loud, you know, and that's what you usually do in an airplane when you're, you're Either, another pilot or even on a checkride. I looked at Darlene when, when it happened, I go, what the, you know, that was the rest of the expletive that, and, when she said, is this part of the checkride? I go, no, and, and we're, we're pointing basically, when you're on fifty degrees up, it seems like you're straight up. And then the thing, the elevator, went the, the stabilizer went the opposite direction, full tilt, and went all the way forward. So we went from fifty degrees nose up to fifty, sixty degrees nose down. You know, I got stalled going up and then went right over the top and, kind of broke out of the, out of the stall and we built up some airspeed.
15:12
John Blum
Bang, the elevator, stabilizer goes all the way aft again, and both of us were pulling or pushing and couldn't overcome the forces on the stabilizer. So at that point in time, we felt You know, what happened? Did something hit us? You know, what, what failed? What, what's going on? You know, we had lateral control, roll control, and, it was like, what are our options?
15:37
John Blum
Obviously, we have no control over pitch at the point in time, and, we need to, need to squelch that a little bit so we didn't make those extreme nose up, nose down, because we started at, oh, forty-five hundred feet, five thousand or so, and by the time a couple, three of these iterations went through, we were down about three thousand feet, and, and luckily we had, before the maneuver started, we did the standard clearing turns and looked for a place where we needed to, if need to, you know, you never think the trash can or need a place to, to park the plane, but we had something out of the corner of our eye that we kept our eye on.
16:17
John Blum
So I don't know how much further down you want me to go, because you I tightened the seatbelt on me, and I tried to tighten it on Darlene, but she's a little person compared to me, and I got it as tight as I could, and she slithered out of it. So she's going up to the ceiling and slamming down into the seat, and still at the same time, we're trying to keep our headsets on, my glasses are going crazy. So if the G load was, we have a G meter in the nose of this airplane, and when we got done, they pulled that G meter out, and we were doing plus, plus six and minus four, which is a lot for, for the old Seneca to take. And it, it stood the pressure, all the way to the ground.
17:05
Jay Robinson
That's amazing. Was there ever, you know, was it pretty much immediately that both of you knew, like, we're just putting this airplane down wherever we can? Was there any period of time where it seemed like it might be salvageable, or was it just from the get-go there was no chance?
17:21
John Blum
Oh, we, we got it dampened a bit by using throttle, and instead of going full throttle and then idle, we started trying the middle range of, of the power, and the stabilator kind of settled down into, just a, a gentle full-going kind of motion, and, I thought, maybe if we keep this stable and we get it headed toward Conroe, we, we might, make it to an airport. But as soon as I moved maybe a little bit too much, the nose would pitch down again rapidly, and I go, oh, not again, and we fight through it, get it back to level, because our, our muscle strength wasn't having the effect, and I thought, well, if we keep pulling and pushing this hard, we might break something more.
18:07
John Blum
And then when I looked back and I saw the cracks starting in the side of the fuselage, from the inside, I could see light coming in in front of the tail, the, the partition separating the passenger cabin from the fuselage had popped out under all that strain. And I looked around, I could see light coming in. It's kind of like a, when you break an aluminum can in half, you know, you keep going and you could see light before it actually breaks away. And that's when I said, Darlene, we don't, we don't have any chance to get back. If that tail comes off, we're done. And, so we circled back and saw that clearing, and that's what we aimed for. And a lot of things went on between that decision and actually getting to the ground.
18:52
John Blum
It was pretty complicated, but working together and getting on the same page, she was, you know, I knew she was an experienced pilot relative. I wasn't up there with a, you know, a private pilot. You know, wannabe, it was, was a commercial pilot, single engine instrument rating. She'd seen some things, and she was able to stay calm. I mean, she never once, you know, I thought being a girl, she'd scream or something, you know, start crying or whatever, but Darlene didn't do that. Darlene toughed it out. She was a true crew member, and we, we both learned a lot. We got down and got out.
19:34
Bobby Doss
I hate to admit it, but I probably would have been screaming and crying like a girl too. I've had a lot happen in my short 500-ish hours. You know, the near miss, I had on my first solo, the, shimmy dampener literally broke, and my, I had the wobbles on takeoff at the water runway back in those days. I was freaking out. It was like just wobbling me into the water. I've had two cylinders crack in flight, one with an instructor, one without. And all of those have made me a better pilot, but none of those compare to this. Like, Darlene, this I assume was your first emergency that was ever declared. John, was this your first emergency that you ever declared?
20:18
John Blum
Are you talking to me?
20:19
Bobby Doss
Yeah. So, Darlene, I'm assuming, Darlene, if I'm wrong, don't hesitate to tell me, but.
20:26
Darlene Woelfel
Thank you. I was with an instructor, it was on a commercial flight, but recently after I had finished instrument, and we had lost comms and IMC going into Easterwood. So, we declared, we squawked, 7600. So, we declared emergency, but it wasn't as eventful as this.
20:50
Bobby Doss
John, you?
20:52
John Blum
I've had to actually declare an emergency a few times, but in the end, it wasn't catastrophic. You know, like one time on, on takeoff, a nose tire on a 737 came off right after we lifted off the runway, and I could see it, you know, fly out in front of us and going, uh-oh, you know, now we got to circle back to O'Hare and, and declare an emergency and land, you know, as normal, as softly as possible, and nothing else went haywire. But, had cargo doors come open in flight and things like that, but as Darlene said, nothing that we had to take it all the way, all the way down to the, back to Earth, and, knowing that the landing was not going to be normal whatsoever.
21:38
Bobby Doss
So I hope we, I think we all hope that we'll handle a situation like this, as stoically as y'all both did, but I don't, I don't believe we all will. You know you're, you know you're gonna land now, you've made the decision to come back for this clearing. What's going through your head, both of you, we'll start with Darlene. I'm assuming you're talking a little bit, we're going down. We really don't have a lot of control. Darlene, you're supporting, I think, more at this point than actually flying, but very much involved. What, what are you thinking? Like, what's going through your mind?
22:13
Darlene Woelfel
Yeah, there's some parts of it where it's kind of faded, just because, like, the head injury I had on impact. I know that on the way down, we were troubleshooting, we were talking about, okay, are we gonna lower the landing gear, are we gonna adjust our flaps, are we gonna cut the mixture? We landed gear, gear up, because it had rained so much, like, the week before, so we knew, like, okay, we stick in the ground. So, we were talking about all those things on the way down. So I think that was our focus. I don't think I realized at all just how I think critical that moment was. Like, I don't think it was, you know, like I was, I was in shock, honestly. Like, I don't think I was realizing. I could die right now, but, yeah, after impact, I think that's when things started to, like, actually clear a little bit. And I was like, okay, we actually just went through that, so.
23:07
Bobby Doss
Well, I was just thinking, too, this plane was full of fuel. Like, we all had not been in the air that long, that long, right? Like, and I don't think a 73 Seneca has a fuel dump switch on it, does it? I mean, that, that, that had to be a big risk for sure. John, what were you thinking, if you can recollect?
23:26
John Blum
Well, that was a big concern. I said, we don't want to catch on fire. I'd hate to, you know, make it through a, an off-field landing and then burst into flame. I mean, that's, that's a real fearful ending. So, We talked about now, hey, we're full of gas. We got 80, 80 plus gallons of avgas still on board. We only been in the air 20, 25 minutes. And, without the gear and, and without the flaps, cause we went on to stick in the mud and flip it over, which would cause a fire hazard. We also wanted to have the engine shut down, the mags off, the electricity off, as we came, down toward the ground. We didn't want any spark whatsoever, cause when we hit the ground, I knew that that, gas might escape, you know, it's gonna, could break a wing. And so I, I, I feared that a lot.
24:17
John Blum
And when we, I had remembered back, I said this a couple of times before, I talked a few times with those fire bombers that, you know, work out of Lake Livingston, Lake Conroe, and they talked about engine failures out over the forest and in the forest fire that they use the trees to control their, their descent and their speed. And we decided we're going to take the tops of the trees to cut maybe forty knots off of our forward progress, just at the edge of the clearing. And, and they also told me, don't pick the dead trees, pick the green trees, because the dead trees are hard as a rock. And, so we stopped the engine, shut the mags down, cut the mixture, turned the fuel off. We're water skiing, basically, or tree skiing across the top of these trees, and then settled through them and came out.
25:09
John Blum
And I didn't realize how hard the trees had hit the airplane, because it knocked all the plexiglass out of it. The windshield was gone. The side windows were gone. So we were getting a wind blast, and, and luckily, I mean, nothing stuck on me, and I think the only injury was when Darlene hit the, hit the control wheel. I think that was when it landed. So my glasses got smashed, our headsets got tore off, as we hit the trees, and then out in front of us came the field, and it looked like a smooth, green golf course kind of a fairway. Wrong. It was probably a foot of grass, and hidden in the grass were tree stumps.
25:55
John Blum
And when we started sliding into the mud, our first impact, it was pretty hard, but it was soft ground, it absorbed a lot of the shock, but then our left wing had a tree stump and spun us like ninety degrees, so we slid kind of sideways for a while, and, and then, wow, we made it, and I'm thinking, no fire, let's get out of here. Darlene was laying, kind of laying on my left leg, or she keeled over, and semi-conscious enough that I, I could, I pulled the door off the hinges, I don't know how that happened, but, and threw the door out over the engine, calling, and then got unbuckled and worked my way up onto the wing and reached around and said, Darlene, we gotta get out of here, we gotta get away from this plane, I could smell gas like crazy.
26:48
John Blum
And, we kind of stumbled out and, and got maybe, I don't know, a hundred feet away before that's all the energy we had left, and found kind of a somewhat of a dry spot, and, and down we sat and tried to assess ourselves and figure out how we're gonna get some help. So that was kind of a fast forward there, is what we, what we were doing, but All kinds of things came to our mind, and we stayed calm and weighed these options and said, you know, at the time, this is what we got to do, and we did it.
27:23
Bobby Doss
Darlene, after you stopped, the, the fire risk is gone. You, you have your phone, there's a Cherokee overhead. What's changed about maybe what you carry in your flight bag or what you do different today after going through something like this that maybe not all of us think about?
27:41
Darlene Woelfel
I pray. Pre-flight, pray at the very end. No, but for real, I think a lot about like just the hardware, of aircraft, and I look at that differently on my preflight. I'm looking for every cotter pin where it's supposed to go. I would say that's the biggest thing. As far as packing, I usually like to bring like my full flight bag, cause sometimes like, I know a lot of instructors will just bring their headset and they'll just put their medical and their license in there and that's it. But I like to have my backpack, I like to have a pocket knife, anything basically. But I'd say the main difference in what, how I fly today is the preflight, the walk around. And I will say like we did those things on our checkride, like the preflight checkride, and John can attest to that. Like we did our preflight right. I don't really think there was anything we could have found that could have prevented it.
28:37
Darlene Woelfel
But now that I know that those points can be failure points, I look at them differently.
28:44
Bobby Doss
And John, it's probably something our listeners care about more than my question will sound like I care about, but like quite literally, this was a checkride you were examining an applicant. At what point did you quit grading and like, let's just make it through this?
29:00
John Blum
Right at the bang. I mean, I looked at Darlene and, and, said, no, that wasn't something I'm doing just to, you know, throw you a curveball here. This is, this is real.
29:11
Darlene Woelfel
And, But I didn't know that. I didn't know that because we were laying in the field and after we got out, because I looked at you and I was like, does this mean I passed my checkride?
29:20
John Blum
Yeah, right. The applicant always wants to know.
29:25
Bobby Doss
The applicant always wants to know.
29:28
Jay Robinson
I meant to, I meant to ask you all earlier, how from, from start to we're stopped in the field, how long do you all think that was? Cause we talk about all these different steps and stages, but I imagine this can't have been very long.
29:43
Darlene Woelfel
20 minutes?
29:45
Jay Robinson
Oh, really?
29:46
Darlene Woelfel
From takeoff, maybe?
29:47
Jay Robinson
Like from takeoff? No, no, from, from the bang, if you will.
29:50
Darlene Woelfel
Oh, like probably just a couple minutes. What do you think, John?
29:54
John Blum
I guess 10 to 15 minutes, as we flew, you know, did a few, extracurricular maneuvers and trying to figure out what was going on and, and, you know, and Darlene, you know, trying to get the mayday. It was kinda, it's kinda funny now, but we were still on Conroe tower frequency and Darlene goes, mayday, mayday, you know, Seneca, whatever. We, we have a loss of in-flight control and, and she said, mayday twice, and the tower controller comes back on and says, what? Like, what? And we didn't have time to really say it again, so we just figured he heard it and other people on the frequency heard it. And, so, and a few minutes later, you know, we're getting it under control and figuring that we gotta get down so the tail stays on.
30:46
John Blum
And Yeah, ten, fifteen minutes at the most making these decisions, and at the time when you're in it, it was kind of like a dream, you know, you're running in that dream kind of slow-mo, and, things are just unfolding.
31:02
Jay Robinson
It's amazing. I had, I had no idea it was that long that you guys were battling this. That's, quite the, quite the thing to deal with, for sure. So we've been talking a lot about the, the incident itself, if you will, kind of tell us, tell us about the days and weeks and months after that, if we kind of continue that way.
31:21
Darlene Woelfel
Yeah, I can go ahead. The, I was in the hospital surprisingly short. I thought I would be in there longer. I mean, I got in there on the third. I was life flighted to the hospital, so I got it there on the third, and then they dismissed me on the fifth. But my recovery took a lot longer than that. I was in a back brace for eight weeks after that. I had fractured my spine. And then I had like 30 plus stitches on my forehead going up to my, past my hairline. So that was a lot of recovery. I had a lot of blood loss. So as far as like, like my memory was pretty, pretty fragile at that point. I was fragile, like I couldn't stand well.
32:11
Darlene Woelfel
It was quite the journey, but I will say like the people who came into the hospital, like I had friends from the flight school, like professors came, and they were like, you have to get back to flying. And I'm like, what? They were like, you have to finish that checkride. I'm like, you're joking. But I think those people that came Like, who visit, who visited me, initially those were like the people that helped me the most because they were encouraging me like, you have to get back on the saddle, stuff like that. And like, that's kind of like the last thing I wanted to think about, but I think that's how I was able to get back to flying because as soon as I was released from wearing the back brace, I think it was the next day I went flying with a friend. I'm like, I barely flew, but I was like, I think I need to get in the air. Like, I don't want this to develop into like a long-term fear. I want to go flying. I want to see how it reacts. And it was hard, like every little bump of turbulence, it felt like it was like my body remembered it.
33:06
Darlene Woelfel
Like I would just tense up. My first flight in a Seneca after that was very difficult and I had gone up with a really good instructor. But Like it was emotional. It was weird. There were things I didn't remember, but my body remembered, like responding to stuff like turbulence. So it was difficult, but I think I got through it because I had so much support. Like we talk about how like the aviation world is so small, but it, it really is small when you go through something like that because people surround you so much after that.
33:37
Bobby Doss
Well, I retell, I, I retell a story from our, our time. We had a bird strike in our Travel Air that was, went through the windshield right on the instructor's side. And, the instructor was great. They got the plane back on the ground in Navasota. It was a, a big day for me to go wrap the plane. I don't think I'd own the flight school that long when that happened. And Jay sold me that plane, by the way. But, that, that, that instructor was so confident that it was just going to be easy to get back in that plane. And, the day of the return, he had a flight in it. And I, I, I can only equate it to PTSD, like Something overcame him, and there was no way he was getting back in that airplane, right? And I sensed it, not having that much aviation experience, but I would encourage anyone listening or anyone out there, this is not a boy-girl thing, this is not a weak thing, this is just reality.
34:30
Bobby Doss
Your body and your feelings and mind are going to remember stuff you don't even know happened, and a bump of turbulence will freak you out. Like, just seeing a bird flying probably scares this guy. A turkey vulture probably scares this guy still today. Don't be shameful of that. Like, I constantly say, this was a big, beefy, strong guy. That has nothing to do what was going on in his mind, and we got to have all this up here working if we're going to be good pilots. So I don't fault you one bit. I can't, I still can't believe you're a multi-engine pilot. I'm not sure I would ever get back into a multi-engine aircraft. So tell us a little bit about how that happened and how you actually finished the checkride, and who the heck was your examiner?
35:17
Darlene Woelfel
Who was it? Oh, it was John again.
35:20
Bobby Doss
I knew it was John.
35:20
Darlene Woelfel
I wanted to finish it together. Yeah, I wanted to finish it together. Yeah, I wanted to finish it together. In a Piper Seneca. Yeah, I will say, going back to the note about what was it like flying again, I think what helped a lot, and I'm so glad, obviously, that John and I both made it, because we're alive, but also because, like, I, he's the only one who understands what it was like to go through that. And he and I have, like, gone through the story multiple times, just sitting and talking about it. And, like, we learn new things, I think, every time we talk about it. And in a way, like, that's the most therapeutic thing, I think, for me to Just kind of resolve it in my head, like not be scared anymore to fly.
36:10
Darlene Woelfel
I think just talking about it, not keeping it inside and sharing it with people like y'all, sharing at different talks and just, you know, random pilots I meet, somehow it comes up. Sometimes I know about the story and I'd never met them before. But talking about that, that's been really, I guess, really powerful, you know, overcoming the fears of it.
36:31
Bobby Doss
That's great. John, anything to add? That's okay, John, anything to add about doing it again together? Like, how crazy is that?
36:40
John Blum
Well, we had to finish the job. I think we agreed that, you know, what else could go wrong? You know, it's not gonna be that bad again, you know, unless, you know, luck strike twice. But I think, you know, hoping and working that Darlene would, would Assess everything that went on, you know, and, and decide that, you know, I really love flying that much, that this is just, this is a speed bump, you know, I'm going to have to retrain myself to be comfortable again in the air. And the thing I really realized, what, whatever student I'm up with, and, you know, you all be flight instructors or whatever, or pilots with people in the back and so on, that I cared so much about whether it's Darlene or any student, that I had to do everything possible to make sure that the outcome was positive.
37:35
John Blum
If, if something had happened, and let's say I was bad enough to see Darlene hurt, you know, that was a pretty vicious cut she had, and it, it, it cut me to my heart, you know, to see that pain that was induced, but over time, the pain goes away, you know, the scars somewhat heal. You know, I I had injuries too, and I didn't know how I could even have gotten out of that plane and went as far as I did with the number of bones that were broken, at that time. So I got, you know, that's an amazing, amazing thing that somehow the human spirit can work through that, but we did it together. And I think forevermore, I mean, Darlene and I are going to be friends forever, you know, and, and, it, it's not going to go away.
38:23
John Blum
And, I hope people understand, when they look at Darlene coming back and getting back on that bull, so to speak, that, that took courage, that took perseverance, that took patience, and most of all, I think it took faith. And, if you didn't get close to faith that, that day during that kind of an event, then there's something wrong with you. And, Well, maybe that's just my opinion. I don't want to accuse anybody of not having faith, but it, it did carry us through, and we've talked about that since. You know, the strength of, you know, laying there in that field, and I hate fire ants, and I know Darlene knows I hate fire ants, and there was fire ants in that field, and I must have got fifty bites, while I'm laying there, but that was the least of my worries.
39:15
John Blum
But seeing the other people that cared, you know, the Cherokee that was flying over and from another flight school that heard the Mayday and kind of made us as we laid back and looked in that beautiful May third sky, you know, not a cloud there, you know, as you explained earlier, Bobby, that hey, everything was going good for that day until we were laying in that field. But then afterwards, you know, I'm so glad, like Darlene talked about her flight bag or whatever, I'm glad I was wearing, one of those medium pants or those cargo pants, and then my phone was in one of the Got this on my thigh, and we were laying, I go, wow, I need to call 911. Where's my phone? Oh, it's right where I left it. It's in that, that pocket in my pants.
39:58
John Blum
And that added to, I think, the ability for us to get first responders, and we were in a place that they had a tough time getting to, and I tried for a year trying to get back to the first responders and say, thank you. You know, you carried us out of a swamp. They couldn't even use their ATVs to get to us. It was all carried us by hand. And I was supposed to go in a helicopter, because they saw my pants were all red from, from blood, and they thought I needed quick, quick service, so to speak. But I said, no, that's not me, that's Darlene. So we swapped, and she got the helicopter ride, and I was thinking, I, I wouldn't mind riding on a helicopter. But then later on, I think the funny part was about the helicopter ride. I'm in an ambulance, I beat the helicopter to the hospital for once, and then a few weeks later, Darlene got the bill for the helicopter ride.
40:53
John Blum
Yeah. And it was, tell how much it was.
40:58
Darlene Woelfel
The bill was $60,000. Not the point where I was like, is insurance gonna cover? That was a whole nother thing, like after, like the logistics of it, like getting my medical, my medical cleared again, cause I, I had very shortly after gotten a letter from FAA saying like, you're temporarily disqualified because of your history of accident, head injury, blah, blah, blah. So that was really difficult, and then the expensive thing figuring out.
41:25
Jay Robinson
Yeah, I mean, Darlene, if you're willing, we'd love to hear about that. I think that's something that people would probably be interested to hear about.
41:32
Darlene Woelfel
Yeah, I mean. I had a first class medical at that point. It was a couple weeks after that the FAA sent that letter saying I was disqualified. It seemed like the main thing was because of the blood loss, so I had like temporary anemia. So they were like, we just want proof that you're okay. So I'm like, okay, I'm going to go to my, the doctor that I had visited after, and I was like, hey, I just need like a clearance. Like, can you write something? She was like, okay. And we did a couple like little tests, like balance, my hand-eye coordination, things like that, and like a blood test as well. And I sent it back and they were like, this is enough. So it was, it was several back and forths with the FAA returning to me, and they don't respond quickly, and then me going back to the doctor and trying to get stuff.
42:17
Darlene Woelfel
And I think it was, so the crash was in May, and it was like right before Christmas of that December that they said I was cleared, that I could turn to my normal medical, and that I could fly again. So that whole time I had been doing I had been flying, but I couldn't log any PIC. But I had been doing just kind of like recurrent refresh flights in the center, couldn't get comfortable again. So when it was cleared in December, it was like the first week of January, that's when John and I went up, because I was able to do the checkride, because I had my medical at that point. So, yeah.
42:55
John Blum
And I got re-cleared, I got the same kind of letter, you know, FAA says, Dear John, I hope you are recovering from your accident. Like, this is the FAA telling me this, but then, however, since your injuries were reported as severe or whatever, you're no longer, your medical's no longer valid, got to do this, this, and this. So we, we went through kind of different pathways to get, get the FAA, you know, to get my second class medical back, and, you know, that was, that was a long wait, you know, they, they, they're pre-methodical, if you want to call it that. To get this all cleared to get back to flying, and that's what we needed to do. We needed to get flying, and that medical needed to have, have been reissued. That was a great thing to get done.
43:44
Bobby Doss
Absolutely. So one point slash question, and then I'll wrap up with a couple of rapid fire questions and a close-up for the show. The checkride ended, if I'm correct, it was a discontinuance. She didn't get disapproved for, for ending up in the field. The, the discontinuance, those listening and those who haven't ever taken a checkride, I always think we all know how this works, but the, sometimes people listening don't really know how this works. So she had to take the checkride all over again. John, as an examiner, someone with the wisdom, can you explain to all the listeners, why was it a full checkride again on the, on the second take?
44:23
John Blum
Well, it was the time that had happened between the, the continuance or, discontinuance to make it be legal to break it into two parts.
44:37
Bobby Doss
Yeah, so it was, there's no, nothing different than if someone would have discontinued on a private check, right? And they waited seven months, they would have to start all over like anybody else. It was, there was nothing, no harm, no foul in that, that sense. One question for you, Darlene, then one question for John, and then I'll wrap it up. Unless either one of you have anything else you want to share before we wrap it up. Anything that you want to share before we wrap up?
45:05
Darlene Woelfel
I, we like to talk about like the technical side of it. I know John's really good at explaining that side. I like talking about like what it was like feeling side and such. And we had talked about it a little bit, like what was it like getting back in the plane? I think some of the questions that I wrestled with, cause John, even John mentioned like, why did that happen? We're still here. We're so lucky, you know? It was interesting because I had a lot of questions like, like you said, why did that happen? Like, what caused that? Because in a way, we're still kind of wondering, like, what really caused that, that point of failure? Was it the bolt breaking? Was it a missing cotter pin? Things like that. And it kind of came to a point where it was like, I don't know, like, maybe one day I'll know. Like, that's, that's my, I guess, philosophy of it. I don't need to know right now, and that's okay.
45:55
Darlene Woelfel
All I have to do is, like, be grateful for the day that I have today and hopefully share awareness with other people, my friends, with strangers who are pilots, and just share, like, the joy of, like, having life right now. So I just wanted to...
46:08
Bobby Doss
That's good. So in, in that respect, your question, Darlene, what's one thing every pilot should do on the next preflight?
46:20
Darlene Woelfel
I would genuinely want to say pray. I think that had a big part in the recovery effort of getting us, you know, in the air, but also recovery and like the survival. One little thing I'd like to share, I think it's like more than a coincidence. My mom hadn't, my parents knew that I was taking the checkride and they had my location on their phone. And they were like, "Oh, it's like around 1:30." They're like, "Darlene's probably taking her checkride." So they checked my location and they were like, "Oh, she's over the Sam Houston Forest. Let's pray a prayer for her that she passes her checkride." So they said a prayer. And then within minutes, my friend who had heard my Mayday call, she called my mom was like, "Hey, Darlene was in an accident." And we just want you to know that she's on her way to the hospital at this point. So I think that's super cool. And I think it's because my mom prayed. I think she had faith that, you know, God's watching over during, and she had no idea what was going on in that moment.
47:14
Darlene Woelfel
But I think when God, like, places something on your heart, like, hey, like a random name comes to your mind or a person, like, just say a prayer for that person. You don't know what it's going to do, but it'll help them.
47:26
Bobby Doss
Awesome. And John, your final question for this show is, what's one thing every examiner should brief with an applicant?
47:38
John Blum
Retrospect. Yeah, we talked about preflight, and we talked about the pre-briefing. What if something goes wrong here, something goes wrong there, we kind of get our mind set to deal with, something that we sort of expect. But in reality, pilots are trained and should have enough of their situational awareness to understand things that can happen that you don't expect, and you're going to have to deal with it. So On a checkride, you can't be all wrapped around the maneuver, you can't be not looking out the window, you can't be so introverted or, or as Darlene said, she was nervous, but in the plane, she wasn't. You know, she, she did her thing, she followed the checklist, she, she communicated, and then when the so-called big bang happened, we, we went right to work as a team.
48:32
John Blum
And that's what the student or the check person should understand, that we can become a team, and, even though the flight check is sort of over, that we have to work together to survive. And some of these failures in flight can be pretty catastrophic, you know, as we saw over the weekend, with the Learjet.
48:55
Bobby Doss
I mean, it's very, very sad. And with that, we'll say Darlene came out of that field and kept flying. She retested with the same examiner, and now she's teaching the next generation of pilots how important that preflight can be and what you might want to look for. John kept flying it all the way to the ground and kept teaching. That's the whole lesson, preparation you hope you never use, a crew mindset, even when it's just a checkride, and the discipline to fly the airplane until it stops. To Darlene and John, thank you, and to all those that are listening, pick your field, brief your exchange, and look twice at that tail. Until next time, stay behind the prop, and thanks for listening.
49:36
Behind the Prop Outro
Thanks for checking out the Behind the Prop podcast. Be sure to click subscribe and check us out online at behindtheprop.com. Behind the Prop is recorded in Houston, Texas. Creator and host is Bobby Doss. Co-host is Wally Mulhearn. The show is for entertainment purposes only and is not meant to replace actual flight instruction. Thanks for listening and remember, fly safe.